[Beagle8U]

The problem is those asked about guns in the home will have that recorded in their permanent medical records. Records that wind up being forwarded many times to other doctors and insurance companies. It may wind up in the hands of government too unless obamacare is repealed.

Still think it's OK?

[epow]

Still think it's OK?

I have never thought or said that it's OK. I just think that it MAY possibly infringe on an individual's Constitutional right to free speech, and the 1st amendment is equally as important to our liberties as the 2nd.

If a patient refuses to answer the question and ends his/her doctor-patient relationship with that doctor, why would that be made known to insurance companies? In any event, if I understand the legal situation regarding that part of the law, that question will be decided by a higher court than that of the Miami judge.