[Lazlo in PA]

Whether kids get this vaccine should be solely up to parents. Government needs to butt out.

That isn't what the poster is doing here. He is pushing an anti Gardasil line using some story about a girl and then links to his own activism site in the vaccine. If you read the end of my post I said Perry's mandate was BS. No way around it. The issue of the post is to slam the vaccine on scant evidence.

Except that children don't get HPV sitting next to someone in class.

What about the hepatitis vaccines that kids are forced to get to attend public schools. Is that one dangerous as well?

[DJ MacWoW]

Gardasil is not proven. I posted a thread some time ago with links. The FDA approved it for 9 year olds before the trials had even begun in Japan. They have no idea how long the vaccine lasts nor what side affects, if any, happen over time or after puberty.

Again, children do not get HPV by sitting in class.