Slippery slope to tyranny. The former DDR spied on its citizens, and no one ever considered it a good place to live.
In my opinion you are either a muslim or an american.
Maybe true, but still shouldn't start making exceptions to the basic rights of Americans. Like I said first muslims, then NRA members, then etc. Governments LOVE things like this it gives them the camel's nose in the tent.
What do you suggest? Let the muslims do what they will and arrest them after they have murdered thousands more? I see your point, and it is a tricky path we tread, but doing nothing is not an option.