"BACK TO THE BASICS (That Built Democracy Around The World)". Yes, I know we're not a democracy, but the word is now known to include all self-governing peoples.
"Reclaiming America" sounds too much like anti-"Change and Hope" and somewhat partisan, which will turn off the obambi leaning independents. IMHO.
Or, AMERICAN VALUES (That Made The World A Better Place)...or...?
I would change one of your suggestions a bit, to "BACK TO THE BASICS (Our Constitutional Republic)" as I don't like using democracy as it has more negatives surrounding it than positives.
American Values would be good in there somewhere also.