To: GourmetDan
We got federal drug prohibition without an amendment because federal drug prohibition really came into being in 1970-71, three decades after the Supreme Court had upheld the power of Congress to regulate pretty much anything under the Commerce Clause. Alcohol prohibition, by contrast, came before the post-New Deal Commerce Clause cases, so Congress needed to pass an amendment to prohibit alcohol. It’s unconstitutional, regardless of what the Supreme Court says, and it’s an abject failure.
96 posted on
08/22/2011 12:31:19 PM PDT by
10thAmendmentGuy
("It has been my experience that folks who have no vices have very few virtues." -Abraham Lincoln)
To: 10thAmendmentGuy
"We got federal drug prohibition without an amendment because federal drug prohibition really came into being in 1970-71, three decades after the Supreme Court had upheld the power of Congress to regulate pretty much anything under the Commerce Clause. Alcohol prohibition, by contrast, came before the post-New Deal Commerce Clause cases, so Congress needed to pass an amendment to prohibit alcohol. Its unconstitutional, regardless of what the Supreme Court says, and its an abject failure." That's what I mean about politicians learning from their 'mistakes'.
Undermining the Constitution takes time, but apparently there was enough to get from there to here.
120 posted on
08/22/2011 2:55:24 PM PDT by
GourmetDan
(Eccl 10:2 - The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left.)
To: 10thAmendmentGuy
"We got federal drug prohibition without an amendment because federal drug prohibition really came into being in 1970-71, three decades after the Supreme Court had upheld the power of Congress to regulate pretty much anything under the Commerce Clause. Alcohol prohibition, by contrast, came before the post-New Deal Commerce Clause cases, so Congress needed to pass an amendment to prohibit alcohol. Its unconstitutional, regardless of what the Supreme Court says, and its an abject failure." That's what I mean about politicians learning from their 'mistakes'.
Undermining the Constitution takes time, but apparently there was enough to get from there to here.
I do appreciate the explanation though. :-)
121 posted on
08/22/2011 2:56:09 PM PDT by
GourmetDan
(Eccl 10:2 - The heart of the wise inclines to the right, but the heart of the fool to the left.)
FreeRepublic.com is powered by software copyright 2000-2008 John Robinson