[RatRipper]

Can the Senate ratify an unconstitutional treaty?

Can the Supreme court overturn ratification if it is unconstitutional?

[Scotsman will be Free]

A ratified treaty takes precedence over our current laws, etc.

[piytar]

There has been a lot of debate about whether a treaty can supersede the Constitution. It's a murky area. My interpretation is that it can, but not in the realm of fundamental Constitutional rights. That's why Keller was so important — it declared the Second Amendment right to keep and bare arms to be “fundamental.”

Given the Keller and McDonald cases, the SCOTUS would be very likely to strike down the treaty as unconstitutional.

JMHO, of course. Why I copied a real lawyer. What's your take, jagusafr?

[MeganC]

Yes and yes.