I am and have done so repeatedly. No conservative or libertarian that I know makes a distinction.
In fact, advocates of aid to Israel are the single best friends the Arab dictators have. Historically, aid to Israel and the Arabs has gone together like hand in glove. It all begain in earnest in the 1970s when Nixon started massive aid to Egypt as a means to "balance" even more massive aid to Israel. If you really want to end aid to the Arabs, you'll oppose aid to Israel because it is, and always been, a package deal.
The fact you are not Jewish is really beside the point. Most American Jews, after all, are more likely to support my position on this issue than they are Bibi's.
Your claim of a "another holocaust" is hyperbole....but then we are used to hyperbole these days e.g. Noreiga is Hitler, Gaddaffi is Hitler, Milosovich is Hitler, etc. Again, if you support keeing Israel on the public teat of unwilling and broke American taxpayers, you are also, defact, for keeping the Arabs on the public teat. I want to cut them both off.
In regards to cutting them all off, I am with you.
In regards to hyperbole, I have to respectfully disagree. Since you do not know me, you wouldn’t know that I have made the same argument about folks using the terms “nazi” and “Hitler” at the drop of a hat.
However, I am sure you would agree with me that another Israeli war could, indeed, end with a true atomic fireball. Or, a true Holocaust.
I usually pick my words carefully. But I understand your point.
You need to read Holy Scripture.
Understand what happens to those nations who abandon Israel.
Do you want us to lose the great favor God has bestowed upon the United States since its inception?
“Blessed is the Nation whose God is the LORD.”
-Psalms 33:12