There is a bit more to it than that, but I don’t have time to respond.
John Paul II (who, as an aside, was Jewish under Jewish law, as his mother was Jewish), had some very explicit statements regarding Jews remaining the Chosen People.
In fact, JPII being who he was is some evidence of that the Jews’ special relationship remains, no?
The lineage of Christ’s family and His Apostles and the retention of the Old Testament are bonds in the special relationship.