So why were you saying in your original reply that I was wrong? I only have one alien parent who was born in the Philippines when it was an American territory.
In my original reply, I wrote:
“Well, in 1844 you would have been eligible, but in 2008 a new legal principle was discovered - ignore the law and worship Vattel.”
I was being sarcastic, since many birthers dumped all legal rulings and started claiming - in 2008 - that someone with an alien parent could not become President.
I then posted a link to a well thought out legal decision, made in 1844 concerning inheriting property, that explained in detail WHY a natural born citizen of the US can have zero, one, or two citizen parents.