I'm very sympathetic. A few years ago I posted the gov't weight stats for 5'9" on the fridge door, and finally dieted down the proper weight range of 168. Went in for my physical, found I'd shrunk an inch, and darned if I wasn't overweight again. Went out and bought a pair of cowboy boots and said the heck with it.
That is SO funny to me! I have done THE EXACT SAME THING!
I favor - but will buy other brands - Abilene boots because they are made a few miles from me in Pennsylvania of all places!
I have several pairs now including a pair of ropers that I keep for dress.
I think Abilene are mostly for square dance but I use mine every day and so far have had no problems.
LOTS of GREAT deals on EBAY, BTW.