[Tupelo]

Wow class warfare and envy of the rich on FR.

No. $200K is not rich. But $100K a year is way too much to pay a public school teacher.
Union membership is to protect the bad teachers.
The good ones don’t need job protection.
Remember:
Those that can, DO
Those that can’t, TEACH.

[Tempest]

Is 1 million dollars too much to pay a corporate banker?

[Nat Turner]

Those that can, DO

Those that can’t, TEACH.

And those that can do neither TEACH TEACHERS

[muawiyah]

BTW, your theory sounds good but in practice that's not at all how things work in any sort of government employment.

The problem is the supervisors (who are going to control the evaluations) have been selected because they schmooze well ~ that's what politicians do a lot of ~ schmooze ~ and they like to have that wall of supervisors well versed in that particular methodology.

You cannot, as a rule, trust government supervisor evaluations of anyone!

Find a substitute.