Remember, again, the central argument of the 17th repealers crowd is expecting some magical smorgasbord of statesmen to somehow find themselves elected. I suggest researching the membership from the Gilded Age up through the Progressive Era to get an idea of what led to the movement to enact the 17th. At least it ensures that every state has a shot at electing someone that represents our views. Absent it, close to half the states would be closed off for the forseeable future. The thought of my formerly corrupt legislature under Democrat bosses/thugs for nearly 140 years choosing puppets/hacks without interruption is a sickening notion.
Theory meets reality - you do have a point. However, if the issue is an informed electorate electing wise men of character to operate government, we must first take over the schools and assure that we meet both of the “Two Essentials of All Human Societies”.
Those are:
1. Raise and acculturate the next generation.
2. Pass on the territory to that next generation in a livable condition.
Failure of either results in extinction of that society.
So - slap a Pooblik Skool Edumacator today - Do it For The Chilrun!