Posted on 12/31/2010 12:28:39 PM PST by Kaslin
"True Grit" is a tale whose time had come and gone. It's the good fortune of a new generation that its time has come again. The novel by Charles Portis, which sold only about 25,000 copies between 2007 and 2009, has been bought by 10,000 new readers since the new version of the movie opened this month.
In an age when twittering conversation is limited to 140 characters, where children become chubby couch potatoes changing channels with a remote control or playing war games moving fantasy soldiers around on a screen, Mattie Ross is an authentic heroine -- lean, mean, articulate and downright inspirational at the toughened age of 14.
Old codgers who loved the 1969 movie for the character of Rooster Cogburn as portrayed by John Wayne will be disappointed by Jeff Bridges as Rooster. He plays the raspy drunk with too much spillover from his role in "Crazy Heart" -- but the character of Mattie is much improved. This time, we get to hear Mattie's voice as the older woman, a spinster recalling the great adventure of her youth. The cadences and perceptions in her speech are richer and more mature because they're often lifted word for word from the novel.
The Coen brothers made the movie first of all because it suited their sensibility of a Western unusual in its mix of ruthlessness with rectitude, irony with sentiment, satire with dead seriousness, and all in the service of delineating the black, white and gray coloring of good and evil. They wanted kids to like it, too. Unlike most of their graphically violent other movies, "True Grit" got a PG-13 rating.
The novel reads like a memoir. Charles Portis' crisp Southern idiom, poetic cadences, sense of place and specificity of detail lends verisimilitude in a tale from the vanishing American frontier. The novel was once required reading in American literature classes, taught along with "Huckleberry Finn" and "Tom Sawyer," where it belongs. Mattie, however, is made of sterner stuff than Mark Twain's creative children. She has been described as "Ahab's little sister" for her unrelenting pursuit of her father's killer. Tom Chaney, "a short man with cruel features," is her Moby Dick.
Mattie's character draws everyone in close with the opening of her story as remembered a half-century on:
"People do not give it credence that a 14-year-old girl could leave home and go off in the wintertime to avenge her father's blood, but it did not seem so strange then, although I will say it did not happen every day. I was just 14 years of age when a coward going by the name of Tom Chaney shot my father down in Fort Smith, Arkansas, and robbed him of his life and his horse and $150 in cash money, plus two California gold pieces that he carried in his trouser band."
The novel got lost somewhere in the past two decades as America moved into the post-literate age, reduced to a period piece. Readers lost an appreciation for Mattie's voice and her deadpan perceptions that are rife with comic understatement and ripe with universal insight. The moving prose (and the moving picture) show how Mattie's Presbyterian primness combined with Rooster's ruthlessness inevitably prevail. Duty and discipline ultimately fence in disorder by imposing justice, one way or another. "True grit" is the stuff of courage, preserving a fertile seedbed for the next generation as the Wild West is diminished to a rodeo spectator sport.
In the theater where I watched this latest version of "True Grit," I was struck by the sight of families there to watch it together -- children, parents, grandparents and friends of different generations. The adventure story has that kind of sweeping appeal, and the story is even more exciting in the written word. Americans once grew up on literature like this.
Rooster Cogburn is politically incorrect and revels in it, a "one-eyed fat man" who takes pride in his Confederate service and in having ridden with William Clarke Quantrill, the notorious border guerrilla. Rooster loves to pull a cork and rides into battle with reins between his teeth, blasting away with both guns. Spiderman he is not.
Mattie Ross grows up to be a one-armed spinster and a small-town banker in "Dardanelle, Yell County, Arkansas," who would sneer at the suggestion that she is "physically challenged." She is instead "a woman with brains and a frank tongue," but "feminist" doesn't apply either. She loves her church and her bank, expresses Scripture and platitudes of Presbyterian piety with black humor, and triumphs as a woman we can all admire. The new movie should revive the literary attention the book deserves.
Might as well try to remake Casablanca. There is no point to it.
My wife came home a few days ago and said one of her employees saw it and said “Don’t bother”.
I’ll not bother. I wouldn’t have, anyway. Nothing will ever replace Wayne’s marvelous role in that film.
Saw it yesterday, it is very good, old style western. My expectations were low, but I was pleasantly surprised. Recommended for all you noir-western fans out there.
Hope to see it Tuesday.
As the critics say, that book has a bull’s-eye opening sentence. If you haven’t read it, folks, buy a used one on Amazon in paperback - with the original primitive-art cover. You won’t regret it.
I kinda liked the new version, too.
In an ideal world, we could do a remix with John Wayne, the new Mattie and new LaBoef.
...the last line of the book is one of my favorites in all of American literature....it is spoken by Mattie as an old lady.
“This ends my true account of how I avenged Frank Ross’s blood over in the Choctaw Nation when snow was on the ground.
Agreed. The new version is superior in all aspects except that Jeff isn’t the Duke.
Saw it yesterday with my wife and 13 year old niece. She didn’t want to go but was told she was going to see a movie. She loved it. Jeff Bridges was excellent as rooster as was the gal who played mattie. All of us enjoyed it but it still was not as good as the original “true grit” with the Duke. Still worth the time to go see.
/johnny
And I like the John Wayne version of True Grit, as well, which contains a surprising amount of Portis' dialogue, unchanged, but I had always hoped that someday someone would do a more faithful translation of the novel. Haven't seen the new version yet (it's on the list), but when I heard that the Coen boys were working on it, I was cheered by the idea that, if anybody could handle it, they could.
My brother, who is a lover of John Wayne movies, says this remake is well worth seeing. I don’t have much chance to go to the movies these days but I will see this one, either now or later.
I’ an ole great granny - going to see it tomorrow with family
(some of my grandkids have seen it too - really liked it.
From the first day I heard of this remake, I was prepared not to like it.
But, I have to say, this review gives me a little pause.
John Wayne was of course unforgettable as Rooster Cogburn in the original. But, of course, he stole the show. Maybe that wasn’t all good. It’s obvious from the story itself that it is supposed to be first and foremost about Mattie Ross. And Kim Darby wasn’t really that great in the part.
I guess I’ll reserve judgment until I see it, if I get the opportunity to do so.
This actually a great movie. Jeff Bridges is wonderful and the script lends a lot more dimension to Rooster than the original movie did. Wayne’s version was more broad and comedic than Bridges’, and that served the purpose of what audiences expected in the late 60s.
I love both movies, maybe the original a little more.
My husband and son saw it last night and they thought is was very good.
May be closer than you think.... The studios will defecate building materials, but the hackers are close to doing that.
Underground/black-market only.
Too bad they can't figure out the technology without at least 2 generations lead time.
/johnny
I’ll bet I could have done a better job than Jeff Bridges. And I already got my own colt and winchester! Sheesh, what were they thinkin?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.