[Robert A Cook PE]

Question about whether it is a tax or not.

Legislators would not call it a tax. Now, it can be argued as a tax.

But the version passed and signed came from the Senate. So, if it is a tax, then the law must start in the House - so it is unconstitutional that way also.

[Political Junkie Too]

But the version passed and signed came from the Senate.

See my post 149.

-PJ

[neverdem]

But the version passed and signed came from the Senate. So, if it is a tax, then the law must start in the House - so it is unconstitutional that way also.

Excellent point!