Yeah, no kidding. And on what grounds can police order a non-felon to give up anything?
Sounds like Mel could use the assistance of some local Tea Party types.
Under the Domestic Violence Offender Gun Ban, A/K/A the "Lautenberg Amendment" to the 1968 Gun Control Act. Anyone convicted of a *misdemeanor* domestic violence charge (or under a restraining order for same prior to trial) can be made to hand over their firearms (though I believe simply removing the guns from the defendant's immediate control is sufficient). IOW, you can give them to a relative to store in their separate residence. IF you know what's coming and move the guns as soon as you make bail.
Horrible piece of legislation; blurring the line between misdemeanors and felonies is very slippery slope kind of stuff.