The idea is that bettors have the same information and are making informed bets. But, emotion always figures into betting, and drags the actual "percentage" up or down.
A better statistical analysis is the Monte Carlo simulations that Nate Silver does for the NY Times:
http://fivethirtyeight.blogs.nytimes.com/
After 100,000 simulations, it predicts that there's only a 20% chance that the Democrats will control the House in 2011.
I can't link in the graph for the Senate, but the prediction is an 81% chance the Democrats will control at least 50 seats in the Senate (with Biden, that's enough).
This is where RINOs come from ~ Democrats of value to Republican control in a legislative body ~ not to be confused with tired old Republicans no longer of value to the Republicans.
Problem is, if InTrade bettors base their bets on the same polls we see, they’re just mirroring the polls.