The part that looked like crap was the non-metal fascia. The sad thing is, the difference in price was only about $60. It shouldn’t have been a big deal for them, as they would have been out $77 instead of $17 (my deductible was $1,000 and the total cost to repair it was $1,017). So, the difference they saved cost them ten times to correct. The cost of the second bumper, paint and labor to fix came to about $600 to fix.