By agreeing to a settlement and surrender of website domain it effectively shuts down freedom of speech.
Yes, imo any judge that approves a settlement based on violations of 1st amendment rights should be impeached.
And it is sort of extortion, that if a party does not agree to relinquishing that right, they will be subjected to expensive Lawsuits.
This whole thing smells to high heaven. And then Lawyers wonder why people have such a low opinion of the profession.