I clarify your statement to say that we have all seen a number of documents that point to various alleged, but yet legally unproven, birth locations.
But again, birth location is of little consequence, despite the considerable disinformation and obfuscation.
He does not qualify under known definitions of A2S1P5.
The opportunity to make that case came during the 2008 elections. His protagonists, Hillary Clinton and John McCain did not choose to do so. So, it remains an academic discussion at this stage. Perhaps someone will choose to challenge him on this point in 2012. The issue certainly isn't settled.