By that standard, so was Harriet Meiers, who parenthetically had FAR more practical (and accomplished) legal experience than Kagan. But, wiser and more practical conservative legal minds prevailed. It wasn't a liberal challenge to Meiers that sunk her, it came from the intellectual right.
If there was the same kind of intellectual honesty on the left, people would be revolting about Kagan, who clearly doesn't possess the subject-matter expertise to sit on the country's most revered Court.
I agree 100%
I agree 100%