Fair enough - in the end music is music and good music is good music.
Speaking personally, EJ was never *my* cup of tea, but I have enjoyed a few of his songs. I’m passionate about Ray Davies and the Kinks and I would make your comments about his/their music. But I know full well that puts me in a fairly small minority. But in a way, that’s what makes it fun!
I also think I’m more of a guitar guy than a piano guy, and I think that can make all the difference. I once had a long debate with another FRiend, on the merits of Billy Joel. His thesis was that Billy Joel’s music was everything you say EJ’s music is. I didn’t share that view, but like I say, give me a good guitar riff and I’m happy. Piano music - doesn’t always work for me.