There is never unanimity on any subject except in the most brutal of dictatorships, and even that is only public unanimity. It's an unrealistic standard.
But there was a large majority consensus. It's on the side of requiring birth in the country of citizen parents.
“But there was a large majority consensus. It’s on the side of requiring birth in the country of citizen parents.”
Apparently Congress, the states, the voters and the courts disagree about where the consensus lies...