[El Gato]

Had her parents not been naturalized before she was born, she then would have only been a native of the soil owing allegiance to a foreign nation

She would not have been natural born, true. But she still would have been 14th amendment citizen, as the examples in given in the opinion make clear, some of which involved birth to alien parents, in the US, and in which the person was declared to be a citizen.

[patlin]

unfortunately true due the erroneous opinion in WKA.