[SmokingJoe]

“So you claim she was exactly right, and then say she was wrong. Which is it?”

You obviously can't read.
I say she was exactly right and was exactly right again.
There is no “she was wrong” anywhere in my post, despite your pathetic attempt to put it there.

[CharlesWayneCT]

Here were your two statements:

1. No mistake. She was exactly right in what she said on that interview.
2. If you have the right to ask any question, you are right to ask that question.

In her facebook post, Sarah Palin said that sometimes you have a right to ask a question, but that question is not right to ask. She gave a specific example, the left questioning her and asking her to prove Trig was her son.

So while you say that having a right to ask a question means you are RIGHT to ask the question, you are contradicting what Sarah Palin said.

So you claimed she was exactly right, and then contradicted her statement with your statement.

Maybe my mistake was in thinking you believed YOUR statement. Maybe you made a statement you KNOW is wrong, so as to show that Sarah was right by contrast.

Mostly I think you just misunderstood what she said in her facebook entry. She clearly said that having the RIGHT to ask a question doesn't mean it IS RIGHT to ask the question. She gave the specific example of questions about her son Trig, and then said she would never ask Obama about his birth certificate.