“Organic means living basically.
No, it doesn’t. VanShuyten addressed that in #100. See what I mean about listening to the answers?”
Yes it does...you can not have organic without life...I posted the definition for you long ago. VanShuyten is wrong.
So, you still have not answered the question about how life could have begun before life existed. The reason is because you cannot. No one can, except those who understand that God created life. It is really a no brainer...really. If you would spend a little time contemplating the question and not just accepting crap for fact you will come to see the truth. If, we understood how life was created before life we could create new life (not duplicate what is here or vary what is here, truly create life), we cannot.
Now, how come there is not new life, not variations of existing life, but new species popping up in your yard everyday? We truly have a soup now to create new life, but somehow it does not occur. Indeed, from what we are to understand there are fewer species now...how can that be? Don’t just parrot what others have said, think think think!!!
This is bizarre. Your very own posted definition, which VanShuyten quoted back at you, said "organic" "formerly comprised only those existing in or derived from plants or animals, but that now includes all other compounds of carbon." "Formerly" means "not any more."
Organic compounds are produced by living things. Inorganic compounds are produced by non-living natural processes or by human intervention in the laboratory.you still have not answered the question about how life could have begun before life existed.This was the most common definition of "organic" until Wohler's 1828 synthesis of urea (an organic compound) from ammonium cyanate (a salt, and therefore inorganic). But we no longer use this definition, for the simple reason that many compounds that everyone agrees are organic -- including "natural products" which are routinely made by living things -- have been synthesized by humans. Some of these natural products are synthesized by the ton. And unquestionably organic molecules, such as the amino acid glycine, have been found in interstellar space where there are no living things.
Some people apparently still think this definition should hold, but it's just not so.
That's because [voice of Mona Lisa Vito], "It's a bullsh*t question, it's impossible to answer!" It's based on a false premise, as you've been shown.