“The way I see it, “pro-HOA” means you are taking the side of the neighbors in the community, all of whom are presumably abiding by the rules they originally agreed to. Why is that a bad thing?”
I didn’t say it was a bad thing. I asked what a reasonble solution might be. The people have been trying to sell the house since 07. They’ve reduced the price and still no offers. The associated content article said they inherited the house. What should happen until they sell it. Should they be evicted.
I thought they had lived there since the child was an infant (pre-2007). If that’s correct, then it seems the “reasonable” solution from the perspective of the other tenants (a.k.a. HOA) has already been tried. Someone will buy the house if the price reduces enough. It may not be what they want, but it will be sold. As to the question of the HOA “setting the price”, I don’t know if that is legal.