So don't get touchy when I point out that your dispute with this author contains the sweeping generalities and meaningless discussion you find so "offensive."
Think about it, what do you do? Someone presents data, and "it's not good enough." Someone else turns the discussion toward the abstract, and "it's a sweeping generality." Why don't you post some data yourself so you can get a dose of your own medicine?
Care to trade Will88 for dennisw?