My take on this, which comes from this article alone, is that Penn Jillette was dredging up the church's dark history. So, is that history lies and garbage and if so what dark history would Donohue have to address?
If you read the article, you would see the lies that Donohue was addressing. Where in the article does it state anything about the church’s dark history being dredged up by Penn & Teller? I stated that in my post, it wasn’t in the article.
Donohue was addressing particular points brought up in the show.
Read the actual article, not just my post and then refer to it as the article.