I was referring (implicitly) to the Donofrio v. Wells case and SCOTUS's refusal to grant cert, without comment. The substance of Donofrio's case, as I'm sure you are aware, has nothing to do with his place of birth - in fact, I believe he stipulates that it's HI - and everything to do with the "natural born" clause.
But, you're right insomuch that this "natural born" citizen clause and it's contemporary relevance to presidential eligibility has never been fully - or even partially - litigated. It doesn't appear that's going to change in the foreseeable future.
Over at Fort Hood, there was a SGT who refused to deploy because the Afghanistan war was “illegal and immoral.” I’m having a hard time seeing why CPT Rhodes is and different from SGT Bishop.
“I was referring (implicitly) to the Donofrio v. Wells case and SCOTUS’s refusal to grant cert, without comment.” He (& Cort) had the wrong defendants.