ummmm hello .....isnt that stealing???
Ding...Ding...Ding...we have a winner--in fact, the author does distinguish between a "need-based or wish-based concept of rights" and "rational rights". I say that he shouldn't fall into the trap of calling Health Care (Medical Treatment) a right at all, but should merely call it a service.
bah ... we are just living in the past ..... 233 years ago ...
dont worry though Obama is in the process of doing away with that pesky constitution thing right now ...