Autocracy and the Decline of the Arabs

WSJ ^ | AUGUST 6, 2009 | FOUAD AJAMI

[nuconvert]

‘It made me feel so jealous,” said Abdulmonem Ibrahim, a young Egyptian political activist, of the recent upheaval in Iran. “We are amazed at the organization and speed with which the Iranian movement has been functioning. In Egypt you can count the number of activists on your hand.” This degree of “Iran envy” is a telling statement on the stagnation of Arab politics. It is not pretty, Iran’s upheaval, but grant the Iranians their due: They have gone out into the streets to contest the writ of the theocrats.

In contrast, little has stirred in Arab politics of late. The Arabs, by their own testimony, have become spectators to their history. A struggle rages between the Iranian theocracy and the Pax Americana for primacy in the Persian Gulf and the Levant. The Arabs have the demography—360 million people by latest count—and the wealth to balance Iran’s power. But they have taken a pass in the hope that America—or Israel, for that matter—would shatter the Iranian bid for hegemony.

We are now in the midst of one of those periodic autopsies of the Arab condition. The trigger is the publication last month of the Arab Human Development Report 2009, the fifth of a series of reports by the by the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) on the state of the contemporary Arab world.

The first of these reports, published in 2002, was treated with deference. A group of Arab truth-tellers, it was believed, had broken with the evasions and the apologetics to tell of the sordid condition of Arab society—the autocratic political culture, the economic stagnation, the cultural decay.

[pnh102]

I don’t really see much hope for most a-rab opposition groups. Most seem more intent on just putting in a different dictator instead of effecting real change.

[denydenydeny]

This is the great recurring theme in Ajami’s work, the way that poisonous ideologies—nationalism, Islamism—have stunted and neutered the Arab nation’s healthy aspirations, leaving no thinkable alternatives to the banana republics that rule them now.

Fouad Ajami is always a treasure. Great article.

[nuconvert]

pong