Here’s my scenario, for what its worth. Obama was born in Hawai’i as an American citizen. When he moved to Indonesia following his mother’s marriage to Lolo Soetoro, he became an Indonesian citizen. It has been highly publicized that Indonesia does not allow dual citizenship.
Obama being a citizen of Indonesia would explain his ability to travel to Pakistan. It would also explain why his college records were never released as he attended as a foreign student.
Now here’s the $64,000 question: did Obama ever apply to become an American citizen once again?