I think they were BOTH right.
Zelda was a very interesting person. I think she always had mental problems which got worse the older she got. F. Scott must have really loved her as he put up with a lot from her. I am pretty sure she was the basis for “The Great Gatsby” love, and that Fitzgerald was Gatsby.
Her Father was the Chief Justice of the Alabama Supreme Court. I used to drive by their house often in Montgomery, on Sayre street naturally.