Posted on 04/30/2009 1:13:32 PM PDT by mojito
It comes at about the 5:50 mark. Cliff May asks Stewart whether Truman's use of the atomic bomb was a war crime, Stewart ruminates and then responds with an unequivocal "yes." He's certainly not the only American who would take that view, but it's a useful reminder that the most vocal and popular criticism of the Bush administration's war on terror policies comes from people who, if they were being as honest as Stewart, would also judge Lincoln (suspension of habeas), FDR (internment), and Truman (use of nuclear weapons) as war criminals or tyrants or worse.
Stewart repeats the charge again later in the interview, but you have to wonder whether this was one of the rare times that he just got outmaneuvered on his own show. Serious people have debated Truman's decision for 60 years, but even those who disagree with that decision rarely describe it as "criminal." And if it was criminal, whatever crimes the left alleges of President Bush seem pretty trivial in comparison.
To the left, every great figure in American history, with the grand exception of Martin Luther King, is a criminal.
That’s how the left views their country.
Stewart- king of the ‘armchair quarterbacks’....
Oh, gawd.
Hey, John, you’re 50 or so, ask your Dad if he had been a WW2 vet, and facing the invasion of Japan, whether he supported the bombdrops.
One little not so well known secret is many, many Japanese were thankful the war ended, since otherwise, all men and kids were to be used in kamikaze type attacks all over the country against American troops.
The costs would have made the horrendous casualty lists of Hiroshima and Nagasaki look like child’s play.
That's the end of that discussion.
...and all the sinners saints.
Just keep repeating this:
John Stewart is a comedian...John Stewart is a comedian...John Stewart is a comedian...
From what I hear, MLK, Jr. was just a womanizer and palagerist.
My late father’s life, and millions of others, were spared because President Truman had the stones to do the right thing.
>>war criminals or tyrants or worse.
Hell, don’t forget Woodrow Wilson’s sterling record on civil right and ethnic concerns, not to mention free speech.
German Americans were pretty badly treated, to say the least..
Yes Jon you should thank your lucky stars for these “War Criminals”. They made it possible for you to live in a Country where you can make a living being a Commie Propagandist and liberal butt-boy! (Although if Hitler had won I guess you would be asking what Enchanted him most about the Holocaust?
When you’re filled with self-loathing and cultural self-hatred for the United States, any incident which demonstrates real or potential wrong-doing by the country or its citizens is considered criminal because it confirms your view of the world.
Washington and his men shot down Hessians at a holiday celebration, I believe. And he’s a slave owner. So the country was a criminal enterprise from its founding.
And so the bullsh*t goes. Sadly, the Jon Stewarts of the world will discover the weary truth that it is easier to tear something down than to build it up.
And the Dyke Dollar worked out for 'em real good, too.
Oh, wait.....
When you’re filled with self-loathing and cultural self-hatred for the United States, any incident which demonstrates real or potential wrong-doing by the country or its citizens is considered criminal because it confirms your view of the world.
Washington and his men shot down Hessians at a holiday celebration, I believe. And he’s a slave owner. So the country was a criminal enterprise from its founding.
And so the bullsh*t goes. Sadly, the Jon Stewarts of the world will discover the weary truth that it is easier to tear something down than to build it up.
What the likes of Stewart don’t understand is that the US killed far more Japanese in the firebombing campaign that immediately preceded the nuke attacks than in the latter. Furthermore, he does not seem to comprehend that he very likely would not be on Earth to criticize leaders like Truman had he decided to invade the main islands (we did invade Imperial Japanese territory, but Iwo Jima and Okinawa as bad as they were would pale next to the main island) as his father, my father, and many more fathers of Boomers would have been killed there. It would have been history-changing, indeed. Stewart would be well-advised to read some history before spouting off.
I know lots of people who finished that war and who would have been involved with the invasion of Japan if the bomb had not ended that war.
I had the opportunity to see the prep the Japanese had made for the expected invasion and I will promise the killing would have been huge.
If Stewart somehow were to “see the light” and change his humor, in the same way Dennis Miller did, it would be enormously beneficial. He is the news source of many 30 and younger. At some point it seems that logic could kick in, it has happened to others. So, everybody, let’s pray or visualise or both that this might happen. Desperate times call for desperate measures.
“John Stewart is a comedian”
Bingo. I think he gets way too much credit.
No truer words ever said.
So a full-scale assault on the Japanese mainland with hundreds of thousands of American dead, dwarfed by the millions of Japanese who would have killed, how does that rate on your worthless, uneducated, historically ignorant “war criminal” scale?
Why am I even wasting the time to respond to an over-rated nothing like Stewart?
Disclaimer: Opinions posted on Free Republic are those of the individual posters and do not necessarily represent the opinion of Free Republic or its management. All materials posted herein are protected by copyright law and the exemption for fair use of copyrighted works.