What was your original question? Your reply was in repsonse to a post I had made to someone else.
(put forth by cartervt) Then he asked that you account for first life. My question to you is the same. You never addressed these issues.
I think you and I know that the scientific evidence is repleat with methodological scientific inquiry which has proven that the universe had a beginning, so we can dispense inane posturing with ruminations on the Theory of General Relativity, the background radation found by Wilson and Penzias, Hoyls statements regarding the 2nd Law, the objective findings of COBE and WMAP, the law of causality, Kalam's Cosmological Arguement, and so on.
Given your correct assertion that the universe had a beninning I ask you, "If there is no God, why is there anything at all? Why is there something rather than nothing?" Please remember before the BIg Bang, there was nothing, no time, no space, no matter, no energy. Nothing.Who or what decided to bring forth a universe from nothing?
If you would just answer carters question, and my additional question I will not ask any more from you.