[Buck W.]

“Credible” scientists who don’t want to be embarrassed in peer review draw conclusions based on science. Are you claiming that the geology of Surtsey is the same as the geology of Alberta? Are you REALLY claiming that?

[editor-surveyor]

"Are you claiming that the geology of Surtsey is the same as the geology of Alberta? Are you REALLY claiming that?"

What a stupid strawman!

Since she made no such declaration, and since there is no reason to think that she would have, why would you ask such an irrelevant and ignorant question, except to cause confusion, and disinformation?

[metmom]

mm:But *credible* scientists routinely extrapolate variation within species to long term macroevolution all the time. So why is it a strategy that's valid in one branch of science and not another?

BW:“Credible” scientists who don’t want to be embarrassed in peer review draw conclusions based on science. Are you claiming that the geology of Surtsey is the same as the geology of Alberta? Are you REALLY claiming that?

Could you answer the question instead of accusing me of something I neither said nor implied?

Is there an evo around who could actually reply to what someone asks instead of replying to a strawman they constructed about the person they're replying to?