Do you think the story of Adam and Eve is allegorical?
If so, then is original sin allegorical?
If so, is Christ's victory over sin also merely an allegory?
You are the one who made the claim that evolution and Christianity are wholly consistent belief systems. I think if that's true you should be able to answer my questions, which you clearly cannot do.
It is sad that your faith is so weak that you find solace in silly paradoxes. It is sad that you limit the scope of your faith to the equivalent of a scorecard. I suppose that there is room for folks of your perspective in Christianity, but I really don’t think that Jesus is too happy about it.