We have a winner!!!!!!
I have been reading these posts from the beginning and many of you have really good points on the 8 or 9 sides of the issue, but here is my theory: The music you remember the fondest is what was playing when your hormones were raging their fiercest. It is not intellectual, it is primal. Just, think about it.
When I hear the songs of my youth and am reminded of the girlfriends of my youth I have a “reaction”. Maybe, not really “hard” evidence, but, it’s a good theory.
I tend to think it just coincidence that my hormones were raging at the same time as the music was at a height in quality.
I don't think that in 50 years an ad agency will spend a million dollars to use “Baby Got Back” (about the big butts of certain ladies) to hype a product.
Regardless of the why’s I know that there's a couple of songs from back then that still melt my heart.