How many times do I need to explain this to you?
I was never posting about the haloing. I never tried to "disprove haloing". I was addressing another matter entirely, one which Polarik says is proof of fogery.
Here you are trying to prove that ringing or haloing does not occur during the photoshop process
And here I am almost laughing out loud at your failure to understand what you have just done for me
all on this very thread!
By all means keep on exposing yourself I'm laughing at you and will continue to point out that you gave the best example of how haloing or ringing as you call it is constant with photoshop forgery.