[Neidermeyer]

Does anyone know if Edmunds, NADA, and Kelly are really accurate these days?
*****************************************************
Of course not Silly! Those books are printed for schmucks that buy retail, they have never been objective ,, their purpose is to get you thinking you’re getting a good deal on that car and on your trade-in... The only book that you should consult is the black book for the auction house (Manheim etc.) ..

[Ronaldus Magnus Reagan]

Of course not Silly! Those books are printed for schmucks that buy retail, they have never been objective ,, their purpose is to get you thinking you’re getting a good deal on that car and on your trade-in... The only book that you should consult is the black book for the auction house (Manheim etc.) ..

The Galves book still works very well to get a real price and even the small guy like me can go to their websaite and pay a small fee for a trade-in quote. Last I heard, most, if not all, used car dealers still use Galves.

[RushingWater]

Does anyone know if Edmunds, NADA, and Kelly are really accurate these days?
***************************************************** Of course not Silly! Those books are printed for schmucks that buy retail, they have never been objective ,, their purpose is to get you thinking you’re getting a good deal on that car and on your trade-in... The only book that you should consult is the black book for the auction house (Manheim etc.) ..

Thanks for your response in letting me down gently! I have noticed that Edmunds is always the low price, NADA is middle and NADA is what State Farm uses if you have a total loss (which is a lot better than Geico will do for you).

I'll check out Manheim - have you used them much??