[[Maybe it doesn’t make any sense to you, but telling them they’ll never be able to figure it out virtually guarantees that they’re going to want to try to do exactly that]]
No, it makes sense- I’m not maligning hteir attempts, but really, IF this turns out ot be a law, and biology as we know it always follows this law, and metainfo simply can’t biologically arise, then I think it will be a futile attempt to figure it out. I’m not stating htye shouldn’t even try- but there just comes a time when it’s beyond reasonability to keep suggesting that nature is capable of osmehting it quite frankly isn’t- Curiosity is fine, but chasing a unicorn or leprechan is another hting.
For someone who "isn't stating they shouldn't even try", you seem to have lots of arguments against the attempt.