“Holy Redeemer is a liberal Protestant church run by the Catholic Archdiocese of San Francisco.”
Wouldn’t that make it a liberal Catholic church, then? Or are you just using “Protestant” as a synonym for “folks whose theology I don’t like”?
I am using “Protestant” to mean “not in union with Rome.”
I should clarify: If I call a Protestant a “Protestant,” I intend no disparagement whatsoever. When I say that a church that pretends to be Catholic is “Protestant,” I do. An honest Protestant is an honest person. A Protestant “Catholic” is a fraud.