So I prove you wrong and you change the subject?
Thanks for playing....
I don’t suffer fools well..
Spin it to someone else.
How did you prove me wrong? I asked that if the US couldn't survive without Israel, how did we manage before 1948?
You brought up the reasonable point that, while the modern nation-state of Israel started in 1948, one could say Israel always existed. OK.
So then, is it your contention that the US's growth in, say, the 1800's was due to the existence of Israel? Or our support for Israel? Or what?