Donofrio's case was about the effect of foreign parentage on inherited citizenship. He lost (as in "was not successful") when SCOTUS declined to hear the case.
All I am asking for is evidence to prove any of the theories I have heard floated about. Most of what I have heard so far is noise and accusation, none of which advances the conservative agenda.
The best argument I have heard involves Obama's birth mother, and whether she was indeed old enough, and had lived in the US long enough under then-current law for him to qualify as a native-born citizen. But, that assumption is predicated on whether Barack Obama was born somewhere other than Hawaii. If he was born in HI, there is no doubt about him being a citizen. If not, then he's got a big problem. So: where's the evidence that he was born in Kenya or somewhere other than Hawaii? Nowhere, that I've seen.
A birth certificate issued by any one of the United States is an official document. A certified copy issued under color of state law is also considered presumptively legitimate. To hold otherwise is to invite chaos. What if you lost your driver's license, and got a duplicate from the state, only to have its legitimacy questioned by the state policeman who pulled you over for speeding? Common law is still in effect in some respects, at least.
The problem with getting evidence is that people do not want to provide it. To get it, we will need a court order. Catch-22 anyone?
“If he was born in HI, there is no doubt about him being a citizen.” In the delusions of your desires, perhaps.