[Stentor]

A natural born citizen, would not be a citizen of any other nation than the United States. That is what "natural born" means. By nature, the child, would be only a US citizen, because both of his parents were US citizens, and NO OTHER NATION, can by law claim him to be under their jurisdiction, at the moment of his birth.

Within the context of the original post he would be ruled out because his parents were aliens.

[cynwoody]

Within the context of the original post he would be ruled out because his parents were aliens.

However, the original post was ruled garbage 110 years ago. See US v Wong Kim Ark.