I think he should be pardoned and returned to the Afghans. I’m sure they could find something to charge him with if they try hard enough.
I think he should be pardoned too. Bring him to me and I will say, “Oops, pardon me! Darn, I didn’t mean to shoot you in the neck. I was aiming for your face.”
Then you can return him to the Afghans.
I don’t believe he’s ever spoken of making a “mistake”. This is what bothers me and why I could not issue out a pardon to the guy. If he were merely brainwashed...and he came to realize the problems of Islam...then it might be to our advantage to let him out to explain this issue to the public. Strangely enough....he never says a negative word about Islam.