The State of Hawaii’s argument in not releasing the BC is to protect the privacy of the individual. But Obama waived that right when he “released” his COLB. I suppose an argument could be made that he has never released the vault copy and since it contains different info, he has not waived his right in that respect.
Yeah, but a simpler thing to argue and there could be no rebuttle to it is that he says he released the “actual COLB”. He has a scan of the “actual” document online. So clearly there is no right to privacy as far as that document is concerned. So there is no legal reason for Hawaii to hold back the release of that document. Of course it would not show the essential details that would prove he was born here ( hospital and such ). But it would answer the question of if the one online is a forgery . If just one field doesn’t match ( Race - African comes to mind ) then it is an obvious forgery. That could be used in the other cases, showing he is coming into the case with “unclean hands” and because of this public fraud, the people do have standing because they were injured by it..
Yeah, but a simpler thing to argue and there could be no rebuttle to it is that he says he released the “actual COLB”. He has a scan of the “actual” document online. So clearly there is no right to privacy as far as that document is concerned. So there is no legal reason for Hawaii to hold back the release of that document. Of course it would not show the essential details that would prove he was born here ( hospital and such ). But it would answer the question of if the one online is a forgery . If just one field doesn’t match ( Race - African comes to mind ) then it is an obvious forgery. That could be used in the other cases, showing he is coming into the case with “unclean hands” and because of this public fraud, the people do have standing because they were injured by it..