I have a lot of experience in recruiting, building, organizing, and activating local electoral volunteers (community organizing, sans the communism).
We can do a very good job of this, but two elements are critical:
1. a local core of one or more organizers committed to giving significant time and effort.
2. just a little money, to allow the organizers to meet a few expenses and to provide them some centralized administrative and data management help.
I know about the methods that work. It’s been done with conservatives — even in the Chicagoland area. ;-`
About $150,000 should be all it takes to allow a state the size of Illinois to be organized with a huge standing army of grassroots activists.
That is not to say that just because conventional grassroots organizations are outclassed by the new cyber/Alinsky methods they should be abandoned. To the contrary, we have got to go with what we have if only to mitigate the disparity. But in doing so must not deceive ourselves that we are accomplishing very much. Those of us who predicted the electoral disasters 2006 and 2008 have become extremely wary of mindless optimism which is so often seen, for example, on these threads which has the fatal effect of masking mortal peril.