[mrjesse]

MrJesse, I asked you a whole series of questions (to define the parameters) that you didn't answer and you insist on me answering a yes or no question without properly defining your parameters.

If you will define all of the parameters I asked you to, I will answer your question. Otherwise it is a waste of my time.

LeGrande, I already define all the parameters I can think of - I specified that the question is about an instant in time and does not cover some time period, and I've defined that it is for an observer on our earth, and I've defined the number of degrees that the earth rotates in the time it takes light to travel one AU. What more do I need to define?

So just give me the questions again or point me to which post of yours you asked them in. How am I to know which questions you're talking about of yours that I must answer?

Were the two links (this and this) which I provided before where you had asked the "whole series of questions (to define the parameters)?"

Just tell me what I need to answer! You're not trying very hard to work with me here. As a matter of fact, if I didn't know any better, I'd say you're trying pretty hard to not work with me here!

I suspect that my "yes or no" questions are properly defined else you would say "That question is not properly defined because x y z."

Thanks,

-Jesse

[LeGrande]

So just give me the questions again or point me to which post of yours you asked them in. How am I to know which questions you're talking about of yours that I must answer?

Lets start at the beginning then. Is the apparent position the same as the actual position?