[GourmetDan]

"If Lewontin is correct, and all scientists have an a priori committment to philosophical naturalism, the no one who believes in supernatural creation is a scientist."

Ah, the fallacy of division. Nice move.

"If people who believe in supernatural creation can adopt the necessary methodological naturalism to be good scientists without also adopting philosophical naturalism then Lewontin is wrong."

And then, the fallacy of false cause. Even better.

[tacticalogic]

It’s self evident truth.